What Happened In The SG Budget 2024? What more did we want from CPF Shielding, And Property Tax

Reexamining Singapore’s Budget Through Different Perspectives

Our goal in this Alternative Budget Debate is to provide a diverse perspective to inform and get you thinking—not just regurgitate headlines. This piece uncovers insights beyond the surface-level figures and go deeper into what the budget measures may actually signify for Singapore’s future direction. We want to encourage critical thinking and analysis to understand the underlying messages conveyed by the policy decisions.

“We don’t just want to tell you about the $600 vouchers here or $200 there. We want to read between the lines.”—Reggie

We also want to encourage you to engage in constructive discussions, even if your viewpoints differ from those presented in this piece as well as the podcast. We invite you to share your feedback and dissenting opinions, fostering an environment for diverse perspectives to be heard and understood.

The conversation kicks off with a reflection on the government’s approach to Singapore’s economy. 

Economic Playbook: Same Strategy, New Results?

When first examining the economy: Singapore continues relying on its tried-and-true sectors of financial services and high-end industries. Reggie notes that the government has been following a familiar playbook, focusing on financial services, high-end services, and advanced manufacturing. Skepticism arose from the repetition of this playbook over the years.

While the strategy has brought some benefits, the question that comes to mind is whether it will be more effective this time. Would this approach finally yield different outcomes? Has incentivising people and money really created many good jobs?

Is there a broader ecosystem built?

We have the successful ventures such as the Rolls Royce factory, which has created a ripple effect in the local supplier ecosystem. However, they raise an essential question: How can Singapore ensure that its focus on emerging sectors such as AI and FinTech translates into tangible and sustainable growth beyond these industries alone?

Arguable, some progress has been made in stimulating supply chain growth through advanced manufacturing hubs. However, it is agreed upon that fully automated factories don’t translate to large employment. The critical issue remains – how to transition displaced middle-income locals into new promising sectors versus importing top foreign talent alone.

A Shifting Economic Landscape

Policy suggests an acknowledgment of structural unemployment due to technological disruption. Significant skills upgrading funds imply many current sectors may shrink in the near future. While the government forecasts industries like AI and biotech will surge, there is uncertainty if the market will actually deliver. Most middle-income Singaporeans remain in precarious positions unless they proactively reskill.

How can Singapore ensure that its focus on emerging sectors such as AI and FinTech translates into tangible and sustainable growth beyond these industries alone?

Reggie highlights that a comprehensive plan that goes beyond merely embracing FinTech is needed, but also one that focuses on building a robust ecosystem supported by local SMEs. This approach can aim to generate a broader impact and create a diverse range of job opportunities.

Protecting Local Wages or Intervening Too Much?

Next we examined the increase in the Local Qualifying Salary to $3,000 – a pseudo-minimum wage aimed at protecting locals but criticised by some as over-regulation. Dawn shared examples of foreigners’ salaries growing far faster within companies, justifying wage benchmarks. The unanswered question remains:

Are middle-tier locals actually seeing comparable pay hikes or feeling left behind?

A Helping Hand for Career Transitions

Dawn, from her 9-5 experience, provided perspective that the expansive skills funding seeks to spur productivity now that many comfortable jobs offer little growth. The group saw this a signal to middle-aged Singaporeans stuck in declining roles to seize opportunities to upgrade themselves through subsidised education. However, they questioned if vocational diplomas truly equip locals for jobs of the future versus temporary roles.

Social Impact and Discontent:

Moving beyond the economic aspect, the group addressed the social implications of the Budget, specifically on the “sandwich generation” and expressed disappointment over the lack of provisions that directly benefit this demographic. The conversation touched upon the removal of certain benefits and the challenges faced by individuals who feel excluded from the budget’s intended scope.

While the government has put efforts to redistribute the benefit through vouchers. However, would it be enough to offset the higher cost of living.

Overall, the alternative budget discussion shone light on how Singapore’s economic uncertainty lies ahead versus growth targets. While policies aim to cushion disruption, locals must be empowered to successfully transition versus temporarily filling jobs that may not last. Tune in to the podcast to also hear more about the allocation for sports and arts, and if artists should be considered essential.

If you are intrigued by the insights shared during the Alternative Budget Debate, listen to the full podcast episode on Spotify, YouTube, Google podcast or Apple podcast to gain a comprehensive understanding of Singapore’s budget policies and their potential impact on the Nation’s future.

Get a quick catch up on Singapore Budget 2024’s benefit-list and impact on:
1. Middle-aged Singaporeans
2. Married Singaporeans with 2 kids
3. Retirees
4. Single Individuals under 45

Also, check out our other Alternative Budget Debate on what was announced, especially if CPF is a reliable partner for Retirement for all Singaporeans, and if the property ladder is dead in Singapore.

Share us your thoughts on this episode and let us know what do you want to hear next.
You can now be our community contributor and make a pitch to have your favourite personality be on our show.
Join our community group and drop us your insights on this topic.

Tune in to the episode