Singapore Budget 2024: Why Topping Up to the Enhanced Retirement Sum Might Not Be for Everyone

In the wake of Singapore’s recent CPF changes, including the increase in the Enhanced Retirement Sum (ERS) ceiling, many Singaporeans are encourage to maximise their CPF Life payout by topping up to ERS for a more secure retirement. This is also riding on the fact that the Special Account will be closed once we reach 55. While the government’s push towards higher retirement savings is commendable, it’s crucial to explore the nuances and potential drawbacks of locking significant funds into the CPF system.

In this article, I would like to argue that topping up to the ERS might not suit every Singaporean’s financial strategy.

Understanding the Enhanced Retirement Sum

The ERS is designed as a voluntary scheme for CPF members to set aside additional savings into CPF Life for higher retirement payouts. This move is part of Singapore’s broader strategy to ensure financial security for its aging population. On paper, the benefits are clear: more savings into CPF Life equates to higher monthly payouts. However, the decision to top up isn’t one to be made lightly. It necessitates a deeper understanding of the ERS’s implications on personal finance and long-term planning.

Liquidity Concerns and Financial Flexibility

One of the main considerations against topping up to the ERS is the potential impact on financial liquidity. While CPF Life provides a steady stream of income for retirees, we should be aware that the expenses incurred during our retirement are often lumpy because of the different circumstances that life throws at us.

Emergency situations, such as medical crises or unforeseen family needs, require readily accessible funds. By allocating a significant portion of savings to the ERS, individuals may find themselves in a tight spot, lacking the necessary liquidity to address immediate financial challenges. This scenario underscores the importance of maintaining a balanced approach to savings, ensuring that one’s financial planning is not only focused on the future but also prepared for the present.

The rigidity of CPF savings, once contributed towards the ERS, means that these funds are essentially locked away until retirement age where it is then distributed in a fixed amount each month. This lack of flexibility can be a hindrance, especially in a dynamic financial landscape where opportunities and needs can change rapidly.

As with all things in life, the ability to pivot and adapt financially is crucial. Having a substantial portion of one’s wealth untouchable and distributed in drips after retirement might not align with everyone’s financial strategy.

Opportunity Costs of Locking in Funds

Maxing your Retirement Account up to ERS also comes with its own opportunity costs. The CPF system offers a stable, government-backed return on savings. However, the CPF system may not always outpace the returns possible through other investment avenues. Equities, bonds, and real estate, for instance, have historically offered avenues for higher returns, albeit with higher risks. By committing extra funds to the CPF, individuals may miss out on these potentially lucrative opportunities.

Diversification is a cornerstone of sound financial planning. By spreading investments across different asset classes, individuals can mitigate risk and increase the potential for higher returns. A diversified portfolio not only provides a safety net against market volatility but also enhances the potential for wealth accumulation. Thus, while the CPF provides a safe harbor, it should not be the sole destination for one’s savings.

Changing Life Circumstances and Financial Goals

Life is unpredictable, and financial needs can shift dramatically due to personal or family circumstances, health issues, or career changes. What seems like a solid plan today may not hold tomorrow. The decision to top up to the ERS assumes a level of predictability in one’s financial future that may not exist. Flexibility in financial planning allows individuals to adapt to life’s changes, ensuring that their financial strategy remains aligned with their evolving goals and needs.

Moreover, retirement planning is not a one-size-fits-all endeavor. Each individual’s situation—ranging from their health, dependents, lifestyle choices, to career trajectory—demands a customised approach. The decision to maximise CPF Life payouts, therefore, should be made in the context of a broader, more holistic retirement strategy that takes into account the full spectrum of an individual’s financial life.

The Risk of Over-Reliance on CPF Life for Retirement

While the CPF system is a cornerstone of Singapore’s social safety net, over-reliance on it for retirement could pose risks. Economic conditions, interest rates, and government policies can all fluctuate, potentially impacting CPF payouts. Diversifying one’s retirement portfolio to include other income streams can provide a buffer against these uncertainties, ensuring a more stable and secure retirement.

The CPF’s primary aim is to provide financial security in retirement, but it’s not designed to cover all eventualities or to fund a particularly lavish lifestyle. Individuals dreaming of a retirement filled with travel, luxury, or financial generosity towards their families may find the CPF payouts insufficient. Thus, considering additional savings and investment strategies is crucial for those with aspirations beyond a basic retirement lifestyle.

The Unpredictability of Future Policy Changes

Government policies and CPF rules have evolved over the years and will likely continue to do so. Changes in the political landscape, economic conditions, or demographic shifts can all prompt adjustments to the CPF system. For individuals who have heavily committed their savings to reach the ERS, such changes could have significant implications.

The possibility of future policy shifts underscores the importance of maintaining a diversified and adaptable financial plan that can withstand changes during our retirement years.

Personalised Retirement Planning

Given the myriad factors that influence financial planning, a personalized approach to retirement savings is essential. What works for one individual may not work for another. Each person’s financial situation, risk tolerance, and retirement goals are unique.

Therefore, while the CPF provides a solid foundation for retirement planning, it should be complemented with other financial instruments and strategies that align with individual needs and aspirations. Speak to an experienced financial advisor who can work with you to holistically chart your retirement path.

Inflation and Cost of Living Adjustments

Lastly, the impact of inflation and the rising cost of living cannot be overlooked. While CPF payouts aim to provide a stable income in retirement, they may not fully keep pace with inflation (just look at the rising costs we experienced last year) or the escalating costs of healthcare, housing, and other necessities. A diversified investment strategy can help hedge against inflation, ensuring that your retirement savings grow at a rate that preserves or enhances purchasing power over time.


Maximising CPF contributions to reach the Enhanced Retirement Sum is a significant decision with far-reaching implications for financial planning and retirement readiness. While the CPF system offers a robust framework for retirement savings, it’s important to consider the broader financial picture, including liquidity needs, investment opportunities, life changes, and the importance of diversification. By adopting a balanced and personalised approach to financial planning, Singaporeans can navigate the complexities of retirement planning, ensuring a secure and fulfilling retirement.

Before deciding to top up your CPF to the ERS, consider your financial situation, goals, and the potential need for flexibility and liquidity in your financial plan. Seek advice from experienced financial advisors, conduct thorough research, and consider all aspects of your financial health to make an informed decision that best suits your long-term interests.

 More Singapore Budget related topics:
1. More on CPF Shielding, Skills Future and Property Tax
2. The Survival of Singapore’s Property Ladder
3. Changes in CPF; Is it a reliable partner for all Singaporeans?

Get a quick catch up on Singapore Budget 2024’s benefit-list and impact on:
1. Middle-aged Singaporeans
2. Married Singaporeans with 2 kids
3. Retirees
4. Single Individuals under 45

You can now be our community contributor and make a pitch to have topics you are most curious off and favourite personality be on our show.
Join our community group and drop us your insights on this topic.